Vasily Kalinnikov - Symphony No 1 in G minor

Kalinnikov died young and wrote 2 symphonies (not in that order of course). Last week we heard the first movement of the first symphony - a beautiful work that deserves to be better known. Use the audio player gadget bottom left if you want to hear it again. I said last week it was interesting for two reasons. One was the obscurity. The other that the music played was in an arrangement for brass band played by the Band of the Swiss Army - couldn't resist it. I know I'm a confirmed Swiss-ophile, but I think they are one of the best ensembles I have heard.

If you like it you should probably go for a conventional recording however. There are good ones by Evgeny Svetlanov and the USSR Symphony Orchestra, or Neemi Järvi and the Scottish National Orchestra. By the way don't be fooled if the recording says the "Royal" Scottish National Orchestra - it really is the SNO to all its friends. Several years ago the powers that be tried to change the name to the Royal Scottish Orchestra. This almost caused a revolution north of the border. Unfortunately the faint hearts decided on a pathetic compromise.

And now for this week's morsel. This is a lot shorter - by the finest of English song composers. Clue - it's not Sir Paul McCartney MBE

Music for Sunday 8th March

Comments
A further thank you to you for contributing to my cultural education!
Art, and now music!
You sent me on a merry dance trying to figure this one out.
But I learnt all kinds of new things!
Very exciting!
Sleep - Ivor Gurney/John Fletcher.
The words are working for me.
The music is growing on me.

Now, I have to go and listen to last week's piece again.
I didn't like it the first time I heard it.
But that doesn't mean anything.
Many of my favourite pieces of music I disliked on the first "listen".

Oh.
And I have to go and read about Ganymede.
I can't keep up!
# Posted By freefalling | 3/9/09 4:47 AM
You really make it difficult! I know that are some others between Dowland and McCartney, but.... Anyhow, Frefalling gave the answer. I now listened to some other versions on YouTube. Maybe next time I will recognise?
# Posted By Peter | 3/9/09 5:49 PM
Hi Peter - I'm pleased it led you to go and look at other interpretations. It's interesting to listen to the differences between the available versions, even those on Youtube. I chose the one by Benjamin Luxon because I think he gets the feeling and tempo right, even although he was probably past his best in this recording as far as the technical singing is concerned. It is also the recording I grew up with so I'm familiar with it. That CD with the Butterworth songs and a good selection of Gurney is a great choice for anyone wanting an introduction to Gurney. Bostridge although a favourite of the critics is much too educated, and Bryn Terfel too full of himself and self-consciously operatic
# Posted By richard | 3/9/09 6:09 PM
I see you've already corrected the name of the band, but just to make sure such mistakes don't occur again, here are a couple of links (unfortunately no English version of these sites). Clearly it was the Concert Band playing Kalinnikov.

Swiss Army Brass Band : http://www.he.admin.ch/internet/heer/de/home/theme...

Swiss Army Concert Band : http://www.he.admin.ch/internet/heer/de/home/theme...

....and for the record, the Swiss Army Recruits Band :
http://www.he.admin.ch/internet/heer/de/home/theme...
# Posted By JBG | 3/13/09 3:02 AM
Implementation by Forthmedia. Hosted at Viviotech Based on BlogCFC by Raymond Camden.